| # | Champion | Defeated | Date | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eddie Kingston (1st champion) | Mike Quackenbush | 11.13.2011 | ECW Arena Philadelphia, PA |
| 1st Defense | Vin Gerard | 2.26.2012 | NYWC Sportatorium Long Island, NY | |
| 2nd Defense | Brodie Lee | 3.25.2012 | Ottawa Ontario, Canada | |
| 3rd Defense | Kevin Steen | 4.28.2012 | Frontier Fieldhouse Chicago Ridge, IL | |
| 4th Defense | Jigsaw | 5.20.2012 | Highline Ballroom Manhattan, NY | |
| 5th Defense | Dasher Hatfield | 6.24.2012 | Pastime Athletic Club Syracuse, NY | |
| 6th Defense | Sara Del Rey | 7.28.2012 | STRIVE Center Portland, ME | |
| 7th Defense | Tadasuke | 9.15.2012 | The Palmer Center Easton, PA | |
| 8th Defense | Tim Donst | 12.2.2012 | The Trocadero Theatre Philadelphia, PA | |
| 9th Defense | Kevin Steen | 2.10.2013 | The Palmer Center Easton, PA | |
| 10th Defense | Hallowicked | 4.6.2013 | Meadowlands Expo Center Secaucus, NJ | |
| 11th Defense | Green Ant | 5.3.2013 | New Mid-Atlantic Sportatorium Gibsonville, NC | |
| 12th Defense | Mr. Touchdown | 5.4.2013 | The Main Event Porterdale, GA | |
| 13th Defense | Archibald Peck | 5.18.2013 | Logan Square Auditorium Chicago, IL |