| # | Champion | Defeated | Date | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mike Quackenbush (96th champion) | Tiger Mask IV (95th champion) | 5.11.2007 | Portage, IN |
| 1st Defense | Black Tiger IV (NJPW) | 8.5.2007 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Chad Parham (NWA) | 8.12.2007 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 3rd Defense | Akira Raijin (AJPW) | 8.18.2007 | Hellertown, PA | |
| 4th Defense | Lince Dorado (CHIKARA) | 10.26.2007 | Reading, PA | |
| 5th Defense | Cassandro (AAA) | 1.28.2008 | Las Vegas, NV | |
| 6th Defense | El Pantera (IWRG) | 4.19.2008 | Hellertown, PA | |
| 7th Defense | Ricky Vega (IWA Puerto Rico) | 6.7.2008 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 8th Defense | Red Devil/Manuel Majoli/Charlie Kid | 10.4.2008 | Pescantina, Italy | |
| 9th Defense | Buck Hawke | 12.12.2008 | Easton, PA | |
| 10th Defense | Sal Rinauro (NWA Anarchy) | 10.17.2009 | Easton, PA |