| # | Champion | Defeated | Date | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First champion crowned at Young Lions Cup I | ||||
| YLC I | Hallowicked | Mister ZERO | 11.16.2002 | St. John's Auditorium Allentown, PA |
| 1st Defense | Gran Akuma | 12.7.2002 | St. John's Auditorium Allentown, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Icarus | 4.12.2003 | St. John's Auditorium Allentown, PA | |
| 3rd Defense | UltraMantis | 9.27.2003 | St. John's Auditorium Allentown, PA | |
| 4th Defense | Mister ZERO | 10.18.2003 | St. John's Auditorium Allentown, PA | |
| Title Vacated/Second champion crowned at Young Lions Cup II | ||||
| YLC II | Larry Sweeney | Jigsaw | 7.31.2004 | Emmaus Fire Co. 1 Emmaus, PA |
| YLC II | Jigsaw | Larry Sweeney | 11.14.2004 | Reading Coliseum Reading, PA |
| 1st Defense | BlackJack Marciano | 11.20.2004 | Bennington College Bennington, VT | |
| 2nd Defense | Sabian | 3.19.2005 | Emmaus Fire Co. 1 Emmaus, PA | |
| 3rd Defense | Rorschach | 3.20.2005 | The Staircase Pittston, PA | |
| 4th Defense | Chris Hero | 4.17.2005 | The Staircase Pittston, PA | |
| Title Vacated/Third champion crowned at Young Lions Cup III | ||||
| YLC III | Shane Storm | Icarus | 7.24.2005 | The Staircase Pittston, PA |
| 1st Defense | Icarus | 9.16.2005 | Reading Coliseum Reading, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Crossbones | 4.21.2006 | Reading Coliseum Reading, PA | |
| Title Vacated/Fourth champion crowned at Young Lions Cup IV | ||||
| YLC IV | Arik Cannon | Cheech | 6.25.2006 | ECW Arena Philadelphia, PA |
| 1st Defense | Jon Moxley | 7.22.2006 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Equinox | 8.20.2006 | Barnesville Thunderdome Barnesville, PA | |
| 3rd Defense | Lance Steel | 9.22.2006 | Reading Coliseum Reading, PA | |
| YLC IV | Maxime Boyer | Arik Cannon | 10.28.2006 | ECW Arena Philadelphia, PA |
| 1st Defense | Josh Daniels | 11.18.2006 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Ricochet | 2.16.2006 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA | |
| 3rd Defense | Sal Thomaselli | 2.18.2006 | ECW Arena Philadelphia, PA | |
| 4th Defense | Soldier Ant | 3.23.2006 | Reading Coliseum Reading, PA | |
| 5th Defense | Create-A-Wrestler | 5.26.2006 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA | |
| Title Vacated/Fifth champion crowned at Young Lions Cup V | ||||
| YLC V | Chuck Taylor | Ricochet | 6.24.2007 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA |
| 1st Defense | Drake Younger | 8.5.2007 | ECW Arena Philadelphia, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Ricochet | 8.18.2007 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA | |
| YLC V | Helios | Chuck Taylor | 10.27.2007 | Barnesville Thunderdome Barnesville, PA |
| 1st Defense | Hydra | 11.16.2007 | Reading Coliseum Reading, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Fire Ant | 11.17.2007 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA | |
| 3rd Defense | Lince Dorado | 4.19.2008 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA | |
| Title Vacated/Sixth champion crowned at Young Lions Cup VI | ||||
| YLC VI | Fire Ant | Vin Gerard | 6.15.2008 | Hellertown War Memorial Hellertown, PA |
| YLC VI | Vin Gerard | Fire Ant | 7.13.2008 | ECW Arena Philadelphia, PA |
| 1st Defense | Drake Younger | 8.10.2008 | ECW Arena Philadelphia, PA | |
| 2nd Defense | Fire Ant | 9.20.2008 | The Metroplex Streamwood, IL | |
| 3rd Defense | Worker Ant | 11.16.2008 | Arena Coliseo Wallingford, CT | |